A fiery County Hall clash over Wiltshire’s finances erupted as Conservative opposition leader Richard Clewer warned of “basement-level reserves”, only for council leader Ian Thorn to tell his predecessor he should show some “humility”.
The Liberal Democrat administration nevertheless insisted the council would eliminate its forecast overspend by the end of the financial year, with finance chief Gavin Grant vowing: “We will deliver a balanced budget.”
The increasingly heated exchanges came as Cabinet considered the latest budget monitoring report on Wednesday (November 18) which contains a stark assessment from the council’s Section 151 finance officer that the financial position forecast at quarter two is “not tolerable” or sustainable in the long run.
Read more
Council bins chief quits as meeting descends into chaos
Row erupts over resignation of councillor caught drink driving after crash
£3 million windfall means council ends financial year in black
Cllr Grant said that warning was precisely why managers and senior leaders would be required to find mitigating measures before the end of the year.
But Cllr Clewer, who also chairs the Finance and Procurement Select Committee, said scrutiny members had been “extremely concerned on a number of fronts”.
“We are burning through reserves at a scary rate,” he said.
He claimed available reserves had fallen from £51 million when he left the council leadership to £12.4 million now, and warned that the looming deficit associated with the Dedicated Schools Grant could consume much of what remained.
“All I am seeing is a giant flashing red light,” he said. “Basement-level reserves, Section 151 officer’s comments that are pretty catastrophic.”
Cllr Grant acknowledged the potential impact of the schools deficit, which is due to hit the council’s balance sheet in March 2028.
He accepted that using available reserves to meet it would “cause us significant pain” and said a plan was being drawn up.
“I’m not ready to publish that yet, but publish it we will,” he said.
“It’s certainly not my intent that we raid reserves to do that.”
Cllr Clewer also rounded on the administration over a proposed £1.5 million draw from treasury reserves, which was subsequently changed.
“I’m absolutely astounded,” he said. “Did anyone read the report? Did anyone question it?
“It’s a glaring issue, and yet none of you picked it up before the report was published for the committee to look at. Goodness, what else is wrong in it?”
Deputy leader Cllr Mel Jacob rejected Cllr Clewer’s separate concerns over the authority’s approach to the Government’s Crisis Resilience Fund.
“I don’t want any scaremongering around this being a problem for the CRF,” she said, adding that officers were “very clear that they’re following the guidance”.
The debate became increasingly political as Cllr Grant turned his fire on the previous Conservative administration, referring to the £4.857 million deficit inherited by the Liberal Democrats and an “unbelievable mountain of debt” owed to the council.
Cllr Thorn also attacked his predecessor’s record, arguing that the Conservatives had themselves overseen an almost £5 million reduction in reserves after failing to deliver a balanced budget in their final year in power.
“I think there has to be some degree of humility when he launches into attacks on us in relation to the reserves, given that his administration resulted in a reduction of almost £5 million,” he said.
Cllr Clewer hit back, saying the council still had £51 million in available reserves after that overspend.
He also questioned assurances that the current forecast overspend would be eliminated, pointing to unexpected adult social care pressures which emerged late in the previous financial year.
“To simply say that we will sort it, it’s all going to be fine, that’s not a rational way to approach the finances of the council,” he said.
Cllr Thorn remained adamant that the Liberal Democrat administration could deliver, pointing to its financial performance since taking control.
“You can berate us, or indeed you could praise us, Richard, which of course you won’t do,” he said.
Full access to all of our articles online and on the app, fewer adverts, a better reading experience, exclusive competitions and more - all for less than the price of a cup of coffee. ☕️
Subscribe now! - https://t.co/AQ9XF2gcO2 pic.twitter.com/bYvsD2lw5e— Gazette & Herald (@wiltsgazette) April 13, 2026
“We are confident. We’ve delivered it before.”
But Cllr Clewer left Cabinet with a stark warning.
“You’ve got to sort this out,” he said. “I really hope for all our sakes you do, because otherwise this council is going to be heading into very, very bleak financial territory very quickly.”
Share