Letters RSS Feed


Misguided emotion on gypsy situation

3:36pm Thursday 3rd July 2008

comment Comments (2)   Have your say »


Quite clearly, Sarah Singleton, the highly respected ex-reporter of the Gazette & Herald, is the victim of misguided emotion regarding the situation of gypsies and travellers (Gazette letters, June 26).

If it only were Romany gypsies that were involved, I doubt whether there would be quite the racial discrimination that she describes.

When she describes the victims of the Hitler holocaust, Romany gypsies were a small proportion of non-Aryans. Gays and other groups were included in the list for genocide. The six million Jews who were killed were the main category. To draw from immediate personal experience, my grandfather, a Jewish doctor, had to escape to this country with his family where he re-took all his examinations and became a Harley Street practitioner. My half-Jewish father, having been inturned, joined the British army and fought for them on Juno beach in addition to other battles in the Second World War. My mother was English.

In contrast, the Government offers very little help to homeless people, let alone the positive discrimination to those whose choice it is to travel.

Here, I am not including real gypsies who are above the need for government handouts including the insistence that sites are within yards of services like schools, hospital and doctors.

Instead, obtaining funding to assist those who become homeless because of situations like the credit crunch is achieved by Doorway which goes from hand to mouth on a day-to-day basis. She will recall the Doorway sleepout in January in which her ex-colleagues as well as me and an executive colleague from the district council plus about 34 others slept in the church yard to raise approximately £10,000. Homeless people are simply considered lucky if they are housed anywhere.

So one can work out who has been given the most rights.

Councillor Nina Phillips, Redland Ward, Chippenham


Your Say YourThe Wiltshire Gazette and Herald

marthaquinn, Brighton says...
10:41pm Thu 3 Jul 08

I feel that it is important to reply to several points made in this letter. Firstly the Charter of Paris, which was adopted at the 1990 Summit Meeting of the Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe of which the UK was a part, affirmed the rights of national minorities, including the right to freely express, preserve and develop identity without discrimination and full equality before the law. Basically this means that English, Welsh and Scottish Gypsies, European Roma, Irish Travellers, Showmen and women, and circus travellers (who are an ethnic minority, as recognised by the UK Race Relations (amended) Act 2000) are protected by law to continue their traditional practice of travelling, and not living in so called ‘conventional’ or ‘settled’ dwellings. Further to this the Article 14 of the UK Human Rights Act 1998 states that: “The enjoyment of the rights and freedoms set forth in this Convention shall be secured without discrimination on any ground such as sex, race, colour, language, religion, political or other opinion, national or social origin, association with a national minority, property, birth or other status”.

To state that they should be happy to live anywhere shows a serious lack of understanding and compassion for this issue. I find this opinion particularly worrying coming from a councillor, who must be aware of her responsibilities under the Human Rights Act 1998 to encourage positive race relations. If she is not however, I would strongly recommend that she reads Chapter 2 of the Commission for Racial Equality Report entitled ‘Common Ground: Equality, good race relations and sites for Gypsies and Irish Travellers’. Chapter 2 reminds councillors of their individual responsibility to promote race equality and good race relations.

Secondly, I appreciate that the Roma and Sinti Gypsies killed in the Holocaust, made up only a tiny percentage of the overall number of people killed, however since that time they have barely received any compensation for their suffering. They were also refused the opportunity to give evidence at the Nuremberg Trails as other survivors, including Nobel Peace Prize winner Elie Weiesel blocked their entry due to their ethnicity and the negative stereotypes attached to the word Gypsy.

who dat?, says...
7:15pm Sat 5 Jul 08

" before the law. "
Which , in case you hav emissed it, Martha, includes planning laws, environmental pollution regulations, theft etc!

Comments are closed on this article.

Sponsored Links


Local Advertisers


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »