News RSS Feed


Your opinion counts so tell us what you think about our stories. Add your comment below each story or e-mail the editor by clicking here.

Filipino widower wins right to stay in UK

8:11am Tuesday 5th August 2008

comment Comments (11)   Have your say »


A Filipino man whose wife was unlawfully killed at the Great Western Hospital in a drugs blunder has won the right to remain in the UK.

Arnel Cabrera's wife Myra died at the Swindon hospital an hour after giving birth to their son Zac, now four, in May 2004 Bungling staff wrongly injected her with a powerful epidural pain relief in her arm instead of into her spine.

“I look forward to the day when Zac and I can continue our lives here in England as we planned before Mayra’s death.”

Arnel Cabrera

Mrs Cabrera's death affected her husband's immigration status but now he has finally been granted his wish to live and work in Swindon after a dramatic Home Office U-turn.

And he hopes to get his four-year-old son Zac here so that they can rebuild their lives following the tragic mistake that cost him his wife.

Arnel, 38, had previously only been granted a six-month stay in the UK after his short-term visa was fast-tracked through the system.

However, the Home Office yesterday confirmed Arnel had been granted leave to remain in the country indefinitely.

Mr Cabrera said: "I am so glad that my application was finally granted and I would like to thank everyone who has supported me.

"I look forward to the day when Zac and I can continue our lives here in England as we planned before Mayra's death."

A jury returned a verdict of unlawful killing at Mrs Cabrera's inquest in February.

But her death altered Mr Cabrera's immigration status and his right to live in the UK, and he has been campaigning against this decision with support and funding from Unison.

He returned to the UK a fortnight ago to meet with ministers to plead his case for permanent residency.

A home office spokesperson said: "The minister reviewed this case on compassionate grounds and decided to grant him indefinite leave to remain."

Immigration minister Liam Byrne MP made the decision officially yesterday, but the first Mr Cabrera knew about it was when his new passport arrived with a letter at his solicitors in the post.

Alex Rook from Irwin Mitchell solicitors, who dealt with the immigration side of the case, said: "He was absolutely delighted.

"I think he was a bit shell shocked - he's been through an awful amount."

He added he was quite certain Mr Cabrera would now make his life here in the UK.

Although his status is not that of a UK citizen, he can come in and out of the country freely and work freely without applying for a work permit.

"It's the end of the line in terms of his immigration position - he's here permanently," explained Mr Rook .

Now Mr Cabrera must make a fresh application for his son Zac, who is currently living in the Philippines, to join him.

South Swindon MP Anne Snelgrove, who has campaigned on Arnel's behalf, said she had sensed through meetings with Home Office ministers that a positive decision might be forthcoming.

"It was against natural justice in Britain in not allowing him to stay," she said. "So I hope Mr Cabrera will now be able to resume his life and be reunited with Zac as soon as possible.

"This case is an exception and we had to persuade the minister that it would not open the gates for people with less pressing reasons to stay in this country."

She added many people had helped to push Mr Cabrera's case, including Councillor Rod Bluh, the Bishop of Swindon Lee Rayfield, the Great Western Hospital and lawyer Lord Joel Goffe, all of whom had written to the Home Office.



Your Say YourThe Wiltshire Gazette and Herald

who dat?, says...
10:48am Tue 5 Aug 08

Perhaps B'Anne'd Wagon could now turn her attention to fast tracking the '000s of illegals out of the country!!!

Tish, devizes says...
12:10am Wed 6 Aug 08

I am so sorry Mr Cabrera lost his wife, what a tragic thing to happen to him & his son. But maybe his place is to be in the philippines comforting his son instead of fighting to stay here, where if you have lived and worked here all your life you get no help, but if you just walk off the next boat you can get anything you want.... before you slate me, yes i work, yes i pay my way, I'm just angry how easy it is if you're high profile you can get help, try it if you're not!

mind your own, calne says...
8:01am Wed 6 Aug 08

Tish wrote:
I am so sorry Mr Cabrera lost his wife, what a tragic thing to happen to him & his son. But maybe his place is to be in the philippines comforting his son instead of fighting to stay here, where if you have lived and worked here all your life you get no help, but if you just walk off the next boat you can get anything you want.... before you slate me, yes i work, yes i pay my way, I'm just angry how easy it is if you're high profile you can get help, try it if you're not!
well said

spooks, calne says...
12:39pm Wed 6 Aug 08

who dat? wrote:
Perhaps B'Anne'd Wagon could now turn her attention to fast tracking the '000s of illegals out of the country!!!
hear hear

www.calnetalk.com

weirdbeard, Chippenham says...
4:08pm Wed 6 Aug 08

You're a bloody hard bunch. He's hardly had it easy. Is it because he looks a bit foreign? How about we ship a whole load of you racist NIMBYs out of the country and just refresh the place a bit?

worz, Wootton Bassett says...
4:33pm Wed 6 Aug 08

weirdbeard wrote:
You're a bloody hard bunch. He's hardly had it easy. Is it because he looks a bit foreign? How about we ship a whole load of you racist NIMBYs out of the country and just refresh the place a bit?
This country is full. Stop importing more people, and start sending home those who don't belong here.

clarence81, Chippenham says...
5:12pm Wed 6 Aug 08

This Country is full of lazy Brits who act like sponges! We need foreign people to do the jobs with enthusiasm. Worz, if your planning on send people out of the Country I will go as I dont want to be associated with people like you through nationality.

He has been through an awful lot at no fault of his own & wants to forge a life for himself here. I wish him the very best of luck

weirdbeard, Chippenham says...
3:23pm Thu 7 Aug 08

clarence81 wrote:
This Country is full of lazy Brits who act like sponges! We need foreign people to do the jobs with enthusiasm. Worz, if your planning on send people out of the Country I will go as I dont want to be associated with people like you through nationality.

He has been through an awful lot at no fault of his own & wants to forge a life for himself here. I wish him the very best of luck
Well said.

I love the phrase, "those who don't belong here". It goes hand in hand with "the BNP represent common sense" and "I'm not a racist, but..."

worz, Wootton Bassett says...
2:04pm Fri 8 Aug 08

And why are there so many foreign born people here? Because the UK is a soft touch for them. They can get paid a good wage, and send their surplus money home. Thus, over time, the UK gets poorer. Sure, there are a number of foreign born people here who _do_ do a good/useful job, and they are to be welcomed, but by far the majority are doing either minimum wage jobs, or no jobs at all.

The fact is that the UK is the second most densely populated country in Europe. Why? Because of the the huge foreign influx. Why do the foreigners want to come here, rather than anywhere else in Europe? Because the UK is the softest touch for them. Sponging is not an exclusively British phenomenon. Why can't this chap "forge a life for himself" in his own country?

Clarence81, if you want to leave, then feel free, I'll not try to persuade you to stay. This country is full, and any way to reduce the population can only be a good thing. In no particular order I recommend, taxing families with children, executing drug addicts, banning immigration, banning fertility treatment.

clarence81, Chippenham says...
4:18pm Fri 8 Aug 08

Worz your opinions are very narrow minded & ill informed. I agree that there are forign people who do not come to this country with good intentions, however you can not tarnish the rest of the world with the same brush.
But regardless of other people, this man has won the right to live here and forgive me if Im wrong but his son was born in Swindon and there for makes him British (or at the least dual nationality) so has every right to be here.

The Maxter, Chippenham says...
12:06pm Mon 11 Aug 08

Given the background to this case, this has to be the right decision. Mr Cabera was part of a working family, who lost his residency rights in tragic circumstances.
Justice in this case prevailed!

Comments are closed on this article.

Local Advertisers


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »