Family doctors should start charging patients for GP services, says Wiltshire medic

Dr Helena McKeown, a Salisbury GP who is also a Liberal Democrat councillor

Dr Helena McKeown, a Salisbury GP who is also a Liberal Democrat councillor

First published in News

Family doctors should start charging patients for GP services, says a Wiltshire medic.

Making certain patients pay a fee for some services would "emphasise the value" of GPs, the British Medical Association's (BMA) local medical committees conference was told.

Dr Helena McKeown, a Salisbury GP who is also a Liberal Democrat councillor on Wiltshire Council, told delegates that many general practices are struggling to recruit family doctors and charges would help to "build up a workforce".

And GPs creating their own source of funding would mean they could operate outside of political control, the conference heard.

Presenting a motion calling for the BMA's general practitioners committee to "explore national charging for general practice services with the UK governments", she said that years of under-funding for general practice has caused "immense damage".

She said that practices are failing to recruit new GPs which forces them to reduce the services that they offer.

"The time has come to lead our profession in putting a true price on general practice," she said.

"Currently the Government both commissions and controls completely the funding of general practice, so they dictate both what they want, and what they'll pay for, and indeed how much they'll pay for it.

"We are left rationing care in our consulting rooms.

"If we, the cornerstone of the NHS, is to remain firm then money must be committed to pay for general practice.

"A fee for some services, to some people, would sustain us while we build up a workforce who want to join us and make general practice more attractive than retirement or general practice abroad.

"A fixed fee, for some services, for some patients, will emphasise our value. Dedicated funding for general practice will assist practices to take on new GPs.

"If we had funding for GP services we could truly work independently of political control and truly focus on our patients' welfare."

But the motion was shot down from a number of leading medics including the former chairman of the BMA's GP committee Dr Laurence Buckman.

Dr Buckman said: "This motion links unsustainable general practice with charging patients and is therefore mistaken as well as dangerous.

"Why do the proposers come to the conclusion that charging patients will influence demand management? If you want to control demand, manage that.

You do not control demand by making patients pay, you then get survival of the richest, not treatment of the sickest."

He added that the introduction of fees would "appall most of the public and the profession".

"Patients would see this as the final nail in the coffin for our NHS, and GPs would be to blame," he said.

"We haven't worked to create our NHS so it would be privatised by ourselves or harm the poor or the sick who would inevitably present later.

"This is an unethical, dangerous, disingenuous and rotten motion."

The conference voted against the motion but agreed on one which said that "general practice is unsustainable in its current format".

Comments (7)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

8:31pm Thu 22 May 14

eureka+ says...

it is a known fact that because of so called "health tourism" our health system is under tremendous strain. we need to resolve the issues at source, i.e. by restricting the influx of such tourists, rather than by penalising people in the UK who have paid their way through NI and taxes.
it is a known fact that because of so called "health tourism" our health system is under tremendous strain. we need to resolve the issues at source, i.e. by restricting the influx of such tourists, rather than by penalising people in the UK who have paid their way through NI and taxes. eureka+
  • Score: 14

9:01am Fri 23 May 14

politepanda says...

""But the motion was shot down from a number of leading medics including the former chairman of the BMA's GP committee Dr Laurence Buckman. ""
Thank the heavens for common sense.
We already have patients who don't use their prescriptions until they can afford to pay for them, if ever. Chemists regularly advise on cheaper alternatives.
Now some doctors would have patients simply not use the GP service. They'll use their money on what they deem more important - and simply use hospital resources when it all goes horribly wrong.
""But the motion was shot down from a number of leading medics including the former chairman of the BMA's GP committee Dr Laurence Buckman. "" Thank the heavens for common sense. We already have patients who don't use their prescriptions until they can afford to pay for them, if ever. Chemists regularly advise on cheaper alternatives. Now some doctors would have patients simply not use the GP service. They'll use their money on what they deem more important - and simply use hospital resources when it all goes horribly wrong. politepanda
  • Score: 6

7:45pm Fri 23 May 14

Friend of the People says...

It seems that Dr Helena McKeown is a Lib Dem Wiltshire Councillor for Salisbury.

Is charging NHS patients now official Lib Dem policy? Sounds more like UKIP.
It seems that Dr Helena McKeown is a Lib Dem Wiltshire Councillor for Salisbury. Is charging NHS patients now official Lib Dem policy? Sounds more like UKIP. Friend of the People
  • Score: 0

2:14am Sun 25 May 14

carer 123 says...

If doctors start charging people the ones who will be hit most will be those who only just scrape by every month despite working .anyone on sick pay would struggle to kay those costs on top of prescriptions as well. I have been on sick pay before and barely had enough money to pay my bills. The elderly and those not working or those getting working tax credits will get it free like they do now . So glad this idea has been knocked on the head . This was discussed on loose women the other day. Out of a show of hands in the audience of 100 people..only 2 said they agreed with this silly idea. Says it all i suppose
If doctors start charging people the ones who will be hit most will be those who only just scrape by every month despite working .anyone on sick pay would struggle to kay those costs on top of prescriptions as well. I have been on sick pay before and barely had enough money to pay my bills. The elderly and those not working or those getting working tax credits will get it free like they do now . So glad this idea has been knocked on the head . This was discussed on loose women the other day. Out of a show of hands in the audience of 100 people..only 2 said they agreed with this silly idea. Says it all i suppose carer 123
  • Score: 3

8:37am Sun 25 May 14

commonasmuck says...

I thought we paid already, correct me if I am wrong but isn't that what we pay our NHS contributions for?.
I thought we paid already, correct me if I am wrong but isn't that what we pay our NHS contributions for?. commonasmuck
  • Score: 6

2:35pm Sun 25 May 14

politepanda says...

But what is really telling is this:
"Making certain patients pay a fee for some services would "emphasise the value" of GPs"
Charge patients to stoke overblown ego's?!
But what is really telling is this: "Making certain patients pay a fee for some services would "emphasise the value" of GPs" Charge patients to stoke overblown ego's?! politepanda
  • Score: 5

12:50pm Tue 27 May 14

Paul Tucker says...

Back to the 19th century, then.
Back to the 19th century, then. Paul Tucker
  • Score: 2

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree