Official complaint filed against Malmesbury town and Wiltshire councillor

The Wiltshire Gazette and Herald: Malmesbury councillor Simon Killane Malmesbury councillor Simon Killane

Town and Wiltshire councillor Simon Killane could find himself under scrutiny following the launch of an official complaint against him by a fellow town councillor.

Coun Julie Exton said she decided to submit an official complaint to the Monitoring Officer at Wiltshire Council after what she says was an abusive phone call from Coun Killane on Good Friday.

She says Coun Killane demanded she support him publically on social networking site Facebook or he would not support any grant applications for Malmesbury Vics Football Club, where Coun Exton is treasurer.

This comes as an online petition calling for Coun Killane's resignation reaches nearly 150, while a hard copy version handed out in local pubs and door-to-door has reached the same figure, according to Coun Exton’s son Chris who set up the petition after the alleged phone call.

Coun Killane, who chairs Wiltshire Council’s scrutiny committee and is vice chair of Malmesbury Area Board, described the petition set up calling for his resignation as a ‘hate campaign’ against him.

In an email he wrote: “Since I have been supporting Guy Franklin for the council position (for last week’s by-election), I have had to put up with constant abuse from a certain faction in the town.”

But former town councillor Brian Slade, who now lives in Royal Wootton Bassett, said: “The Malmesbury petition is absolutely nothing to do with his support for Guy Franklin in the recent town election but all to do with his rude, arrogant, self-righteous manner he shows to anyone who dares to hold a differing view than his on any matter.”

Prominent community member Alison Cross-Jones, who said she was speaking as an individual rather than in her role with community support charity HEALS, said today: “Whether Chris’s motivation for starting the petition was ‘hate’ the majority of people who signed it have nothing to do with the Exton family or the football club.

“The majority of people have given a sensible argument and say this is about a councillor who isn’t prepared to listen to other people’s point of view.”

And petitioner Rebecca Deacon said today: "I find his behaviour totally unacceptable for a man in his position.

"On the occasions that I have had dealings with Mr Killane he has become verbally aggressive and resorted to name calling when I have disagreed with him.

"I'm sure that I'm not alone in saying that this isn't the kind of behaviour that should be displayed by a counsellor.

Coun Exton said: “I think it’s very true what people are saying in the petition.

“It’s taking people a lot of courage to come forward and say how they feel.”

Coun Killane was not available for comment but a Wiltshire Council spokesman said today: "We can confirm that a complaint has been received and will be dealt with in accordance with the council’s arrangements."

 

Comments (16)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

12:53pm Wed 7 May 14

Caroline Moore says...

I have signed the petition along with hundreds of other Malmesbury residents who have signed the online or print version asking Simon Killane to resign. He has been inappropriately partial in his attitudes towards recent planning applications in his chairing of the Malmesbury Neighbourhood Steering Group, and his recent behaviour towards the Vics Football Club has been disgraceful. He is aggressive towards anyone who disagrees with him, and this has been publicly visible in his endless arguments on various Facebook discussions. His role as Chair of the Wiltshire Council Scrutiny Committee seriously undermines the credibility of that committee and its workings, and I believe his role is now untenable.
I have signed the petition along with hundreds of other Malmesbury residents who have signed the online or print version asking Simon Killane to resign. He has been inappropriately partial in his attitudes towards recent planning applications in his chairing of the Malmesbury Neighbourhood Steering Group, and his recent behaviour towards the Vics Football Club has been disgraceful. He is aggressive towards anyone who disagrees with him, and this has been publicly visible in his endless arguments on various Facebook discussions. His role as Chair of the Wiltshire Council Scrutiny Committee seriously undermines the credibility of that committee and its workings, and I believe his role is now untenable. Caroline Moore
  • Score: 43

3:38pm Wed 7 May 14

meg watson says...

Mr.Killane has never even met me yet when I questioned him over a matter via MMB he insinuated that I was a "certain" type of person and suggested I would be better suited on a differant site set up for locals, I found him incredibly rude and insulting and not what I would class as councillor material.
Mr.Killane has never even met me yet when I questioned him over a matter via MMB he insinuated that I was a "certain" type of person and suggested I would be better suited on a differant site set up for locals, I found him incredibly rude and insulting and not what I would class as councillor material. meg watson
  • Score: 33

6:25pm Wed 7 May 14

meg watson says...

I would also like to say my signature on the petition had nothing whatsoever to do with Mr.Killanes support of Guy who seems a thoroughly decent chap with a lot to offer to malmesbury.
I would also like to say my signature on the petition had nothing whatsoever to do with Mr.Killanes support of Guy who seems a thoroughly decent chap with a lot to offer to malmesbury. meg watson
  • Score: 23

6:48pm Wed 7 May 14

Ruby Flicker says...

Wiltshire Councillors behaving badly - surely not?!
Wiltshire Councillors behaving badly - surely not?! Ruby Flicker
  • Score: 12

8:31pm Wed 7 May 14

anon emouse says...

It would take a real man and someone who really has the towns feelings at heart to hold up his hands and say. “I’m sorry, I have lost my focus and messed up and I will step down”
It would take a real man and someone who really has the towns feelings at heart to hold up his hands and say. “I’m sorry, I have lost my focus and messed up and I will step down” anon emouse
  • Score: 20

8:45pm Wed 7 May 14

Andrew Bisping says...

I signed the petition too, last weekend, with the reasons detailed there and which have nothing to do with Simon's support for Guy Franklin. Simon told me he planned to go to Wilts CC this week to start legal action against everyone who's signed the petition.

I suggested that would be a bad idea (except in extreme circumstances) and suggested this would widen the gap between Simon and the community. According to Simon there is no gap. I signed the petition after this.

There is a Maya Angelou quote that I feel fits perfectly here:

"People will forget what you said, people will forget what you did, but they will never forget how you made them feel".

I think Simon Killane is having that replayed to him now. Simon, I believe "you are the author of your own misfortune".

Malmesbury needs to rebuild confidence in how it is run and I believe this will best be achieved with Simon stepping down.
I signed the petition too, last weekend, with the reasons detailed there and which have nothing to do with Simon's support for Guy Franklin. Simon told me he planned to go to Wilts CC this week to start legal action against everyone who's signed the petition. I suggested that would be a bad idea (except in extreme circumstances) and suggested this would widen the gap between Simon and the community. According to Simon there is no gap. I signed the petition after this. There is a Maya Angelou quote that I feel fits perfectly here: "People will forget what you said, people will forget what you did, but they will never forget how you made them feel". I think Simon Killane is having that replayed to him now. Simon, I believe "you are the author of your own misfortune". Malmesbury needs to rebuild confidence in how it is run and I believe this will best be achieved with Simon stepping down. Andrew Bisping
  • Score: 32

11:36pm Wed 7 May 14

Juliemarie says...

There seems to be some confusion with some people about my complaint against a councillor, it was a personal complaint NOT from the Football Club. The petition is not a hate campaign or anything like it, my son did set it up because of the way another councillor had treated me, and in to a response from the said person that the town loved him. My son just wanted to say not everyone does. But he never expected the response , it seems a lot of people have had issues for a long time and came forward to say what their experience was. Yes I do think it takes courage because it is not easy at all to stand up and be counted. I should know with how things are for me right now. I am being told a certain person has allegedly been receiving hate mail. This is nothing connected to the football club I can assure you. And i wouldn't wish that on anyone, The petition or complaint have nothing to do with the elections either . Nor is it political in any way. It is a real pity that this has all happened, and I hope it can be resolved soon, for the towns sake.
There seems to be some confusion with some people about my complaint against a councillor, it was a personal complaint NOT from the Football Club. The petition is not a hate campaign or anything like it, my son did set it up because of the way another councillor had treated me, and in to a response from the said person that the town loved him. My son just wanted to say not everyone does. But he never expected the response , it seems a lot of people have had issues for a long time and came forward to say what their experience was. Yes I do think it takes courage because it is not easy at all to stand up and be counted. I should know with how things are for me right now. I am being told a certain person has allegedly been receiving hate mail. This is nothing connected to the football club I can assure you. And i wouldn't wish that on anyone, The petition or complaint have nothing to do with the elections either . Nor is it political in any way. It is a real pity that this has all happened, and I hope it can be resolved soon, for the towns sake. Juliemarie
  • Score: 8

7:03am Thu 8 May 14

debsy20 says...

here is a link to the petition if people wish to see for theirselves that it is not as stated in article re his support of Guy Franklin but because of behaviour towards the people he has been elected to serve - http://www.petition.
co.uk/call-for-the-r
esignation-of-our-wi
ltshire-councillor-s
imon-killane-in-malm
esbury-wiltshire/com
ment-page-1/
here is a link to the petition if people wish to see for theirselves that it is not as stated in article re his support of Guy Franklin but because of behaviour towards the people he has been elected to serve - http://www.petition. co.uk/call-for-the-r esignation-of-our-wi ltshire-councillor-s imon-killane-in-malm esbury-wiltshire/com ment-page-1/ debsy20
  • Score: 12

9:03am Thu 8 May 14

James o says...

see for yourself.. http://www.petition.
co.uk/call-for-the-r
esignation-of-our-wi
ltshire-councillor-s
imon-killane-in-malm
esbury-wiltshire/com
ment-page-1/
see for yourself.. http://www.petition. co.uk/call-for-the-r esignation-of-our-wi ltshire-councillor-s imon-killane-in-malm esbury-wiltshire/com ment-page-1/ James o
  • Score: 7

9:07am Thu 8 May 14

James o says...

sorry you will have to copy the http address into your search bar . as can not post direct link..

http://www.petition.
co.uk/call-for-the-r
esignation-of-our-wi
ltshire-councillor-s
imon-killane-in-malm
esbury-wiltshire/com
ment-page-1/
sorry you will have to copy the http address into your search bar . as can not post direct link.. http://www.petition. co.uk/call-for-the-r esignation-of-our-wi ltshire-councillor-s imon-killane-in-malm esbury-wiltshire/com ment-page-1/ James o
  • Score: 6

12:22pm Thu 8 May 14

debsy20 says...

Can I ask the Gazette why this online Version of the article greatly differs from the published one out in print today?.....surely articles should be the same??
Can I ask the Gazette why this online Version of the article greatly differs from the published one out in print today?.....surely articles should be the same?? debsy20
  • Score: 10

12:47pm Thu 8 May 14

ryuk-remmy says...

I would like to say I was a supporter of simon even after some of his less savory comments as he has been in the center of a lot of the changes in Malmesbury which some ppl dont like but since this phone call and his quick turn around onnhis support for the football club ive lost all respect for him and this 'hate "campaign' against him which is rubbish its local ppl voicing there veiws some have been very distasteful and been very bad but this has been goi g on since before waitrose was being built I strongly think he should step down or at least step back out of things and try to earn back some respect from the local community
I would like to say I was a supporter of simon even after some of his less savory comments as he has been in the center of a lot of the changes in Malmesbury which some ppl dont like but since this phone call and his quick turn around onnhis support for the football club ive lost all respect for him and this 'hate "campaign' against him which is rubbish its local ppl voicing there veiws some have been very distasteful and been very bad but this has been goi g on since before waitrose was being built I strongly think he should step down or at least step back out of things and try to earn back some respect from the local community ryuk-remmy
  • Score: 12

5:31pm Sun 11 May 14

debsy20 says...

I have to say that steve.in.sydney seems to be in the 'minority' of Malmesbury re a positive comment because the only people (many) I have spoken to speaks very unfavourable of this councillor.....it appears that the instance of this said telephone call is not the first time this behaviour has happened - people who have been elected to serve on the council have also expressed their concerns and seem to be of the opinion that they are unable to have an say of their own unless it is the same opinion as this councillor. Is it not time this behaviour was addressed as the 'people' are now talking.
I have to say that steve.in.sydney seems to be in the 'minority' of Malmesbury re a positive comment because the only people (many) I have spoken to speaks very unfavourable of this councillor.....it appears that the instance of this said telephone call is not the first time this behaviour has happened - people who have been elected to serve on the council have also expressed their concerns and seem to be of the opinion that they are unable to have an say of their own unless it is the same opinion as this councillor. Is it not time this behaviour was addressed as the 'people' are now talking. debsy20
  • Score: 12

4:34pm Mon 12 May 14

MalmesburyInsider says...

This is an example of press manipulation in my humble opinion. My previous comment and several others have been removed.
All they said was that there have been many complaints attempted previously but this man has never had to answer his critics.
Wiltshire council have no standard covering bullying behaviour and so its proved next to impossible to get anything done about it. Now finally so many people have suffered they have stood up and been counted - its wrong for the paper to remove comments as this is why he has avoided being answerable so far - please can these comments be left?
This is an example of press manipulation in my humble opinion. My previous comment and several others have been removed. All they said was that there have been many complaints attempted previously but this man has never had to answer his critics. Wiltshire council have no standard covering bullying behaviour and so its proved next to impossible to get anything done about it. Now finally so many people have suffered they have stood up and been counted - its wrong for the paper to remove comments as this is why he has avoided being answerable so far - please can these comments be left? MalmesburyInsider
  • Score: 12

5:04pm Mon 12 May 14

GavJones says...

There is a code of conduct for all Wiltshire councilors and employees to adhere to.

I pulled it directly from their website and another concerned resident has hosted it here.

http://davidforward.
com/simon-killane/do
wnloads/

I would suggest the gazette takes a good read through the contents of this page.
There is a code of conduct for all Wiltshire councilors and employees to adhere to. I pulled it directly from their website and another concerned resident has hosted it here. http://davidforward. com/simon-killane/do wnloads/ I would suggest the gazette takes a good read through the contents of this page. GavJones
  • Score: 10

6:15pm Mon 12 May 14

debsy20 says...

I do not think comments should be removed as none of these comments on here as far as I could see were bad, just the truth but unfortunately the truth always tends to hurt people which I guess in this case may have done just that.....The majority of people in Malmesbury have had enough in my opinion and why does this man continually get away with his behaviour ....if we behaved in school the way he does then we would have been permanently excluded which I am afraid so should this councillor - your time has run out it seems as I cannot see that there is a way forward from these very muddy waters. Please Gazette do not remove the comments as isn't this what this page is for your comments????
I do not think comments should be removed as none of these comments on here as far as I could see were bad, just the truth but unfortunately the truth always tends to hurt people which I guess in this case may have done just that.....The majority of people in Malmesbury have had enough in my opinion and why does this man continually get away with his behaviour ....if we behaved in school the way he does then we would have been permanently excluded which I am afraid so should this councillor - your time has run out it seems as I cannot see that there is a way forward from these very muddy waters. Please Gazette do not remove the comments as isn't this what this page is for your comments???? debsy20
  • Score: 10

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree